Elements of maintenance system and tools for implementation within framework of Reliability Centred Maintenance- A review

Ikuobase Emovon, Rosemary Anne Norman, Alan John Murphy

Abstract


For plant systems to remain reliable and safe they must be effectively maintained through a sound maintenance management system. The three major elements of maintenance management systems are; risk assessment, maintenance strategy selection and maintenance task interval determination. The implementation of these elements will generally determine the level of plant system safety and reliability. Reliability Centred Maintenance (RCM) is one method that can be used to optimise maintenance management systems. This paper discusses the three major elements of a maintenance system, tools utilised within the framework of RCM for performing these tasks and some of the limitations of the various tools. Each of the three elements of the maintenance management system has been considered in turn. The information will equip maintenance practitioners with basic knowledge of tools for maintenance optimisation and stimulate researchers with respect to developing alternative tools for application to plant systems for improved safety and reliability. The research findings revealed that there is a need for researchers to develop alternative tools within the framework of RCM which are efficient in terms of processing and avoid the limitations of existing methodologies in order to have a safer and more reliable plant system.

 


Full Text:

PDF

References


AHMAD, R. & KAMARUDDIN, S. 2012. An overview of time-based and condition-based maintenance in industrial application. Computers & Industrial Engineering, 63, 135-149.

AHMAD, R., KAMARUDDIN, S., AZID, I. & ALMANAR, I. 2011. Maintenance management decision model for preventive maintenance strategy on production equipment. J. Ind. Eng. Int, 7, 22-34.

AL-NAJJAR, B. & ALSYOUF, I. 2003. Selecting the most efficient maintenance approach using fuzzy multiple criteria decision making. International Journal of Production Economics, 84, 85-100.

AMERICAN BUREAU OF SHIPPING. 2000. Guidance notes on risk assessment applications for the marine and offshore oil and gas industries. [Online]. Houston, USA: American Bureau of shipping.

AMERICAN BUREAU OF SHIPPING 2004. Guidance note on Reliability-Centered Maintence. Houston, USA: American Bureau of Shipping.

ARENDT, J. S. 1990. Using quantitative risk assessment in the chemical process industry. Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 29, 133-149.

ARTHUR, N. 2005. Optimization of vibration analysis inspection intervals for an offshore oil and gas water injection pumping system. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part E: Journal of Process Mechanical Engineering, 219, 251-259.

ARUNRAJ, N. S. & MAITI, J. 2007. Risk-based maintenance-Techniques and applications. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 142, 653-661.

ARUNRAJ, N. S. & MAITI, J. 2010. Risk-based maintenance policy selection using AHP and goal programming. Safety Science, 48, 238-247.

AVEN, T. & JENSEN, U. 1999. Stochastic models in reliability, Springer.

AYADI, D., AZZABI, L., KOBI, A., BACHAR, K. & ROBLEDO, C. 2013. A multicriteria failure mode and effects analysis approach for optimizing human safety. IEEE Reliability And Maintainability Symposium (RAMS), January 18-31 2013 Orlando FL. 1-9.

BAHRAMI-G, K., PRICE, J. W. H. & MATHEW, J. 2000. The constant-interval replacement model for preventive maintenance: A new perspective. International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management, 17, 822-838.

BARLOW, R. & HUNTER, L. 1960. Optimum preventive maintenance policies. Operations Research, 8, 90-100.

BEN-DAYA, M. 2009. Failure Mode and Effect Analysis. Handbook of maintenance management and engineering. first ed.: Springer.

BERTOLINI, M. & BEVILACQUA, M. 2006. A combined goal programming - AHP approach to maintenance selection problem. Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 91, 839-848.

BEVILACQUA, M. & BRAGLIA, M. 2000. Analytic hierarchy process applied to maintenance strategy selection. Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 70, 71-83.

BEVILACQUA, M., BRAGLIA, M. & GABBRIELLI, R. 2000. Monte Carlo simulation approach for a modified FMECA in a power plant. Quality and Reliability Engineering International, 16, 313-324.

BRAGLIA, M. 2000. MAFMA: Multi-attribute failure mode analysis. International Journal of Quality and Reliability Management, 17, 1017-1034.

BRAGLIA, M., FROSOLINI, M. & MONTANARI, R. 2003. Fuzzy TOPSIS Approach for Failure Mode, Effects and Criticality Analysis. Quality and Reliability Engineering International, 19, 425-443.

CARMIGNANI, G. 2009. An integrated structural framework to cost-based FMECA: The priority-cost FMECA. Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 94, 861-871.

CHEN, F. 1997. Issues in the continuous improvement process for preventive maintenance: Observations from Honda, Nippondenso and Toyota. Production and Inventory Management Journal, 38, 13-16.

CHENG, Y.-H. & TSAO, H.-L. 2010. Rolling stock maintenance strategy selection, spares parts’ estimation, and replacements’ interval calculation. International Journal of Production Economics, 128, 404-412.

CHRISTER, A. H. 1982. Modelling inspection policies for building maintenance. Journal of the Operational Research Society, 723-732.

CHRISTER, A. H. & WALLER, W. M. 1984a. Delay time models of industrial inspection maintenance problems. Journal of the Operational Research Society, 401-406.

CHRISTER, A. H. & WALLER, W. M. 1984b. Reducing production downtime using delay-time analysis. Journal of the Operational Research Society, 499-512.

CHRISTER, A. H., WANG, W., SHARP, J. M. & BAKER, R. D. 1997. Stochastic maintenance modelling of high-tech steel production plant. Stochastic Modelling in Innovative Manufacturing. Springer.

CICEK, K. & CELIK, M. 2013. Application of failure modes and effects analysis to main engine crankcase explosion failure on-board ship. Safety Science, 51, 6-10.

CONACHEY, R. M. 2005. Development of machinery survey requirement based on Reliability-Centerd maintenance. ABS Technical Papers.

CROCKER, J. & KUMAR, U. D. 2000. Age-related maintenance versus reliability centred maintenance: A case study on aero-engines. Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 67, 113-118

.

CROSS , B. R. & BALLESIO, J. E. 2003. A Quantitative risk assessment model for oil Tankers. ABS Technical paper. America Bureau of shipping.

DAS, A. N. & ACHARYA, D. 2004. Age replacement of components during IFR delay time. Reliability, IEEE Transactions on, 53, 306-312.

DENG, H. 1999. Multicriteria analysis with fuzzy pairwise comparison. International Journal of Approximate Reasoning, 21, 215-231.

DHILLON, B. S. 2002. Engineering maintenance: A modern approach. Florida: CRC press.

DUARTE, J. A. C., CRAVEIRO, J. C. T. A. & TRIGO, T. P. 2006. Optimization of the preventive maintenance plan of a series components system. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping, 83, 244-248.

EBRAHIMIPOUR, V., NAJJARBASHI, A. & SHEIKHALISHAHI, M. 2015. Multi-objective modeling for preventive maintenance scheduling in a multiple production line. Journal of Intelligent Manufacturing, 26, 111-122.

EMOVON, I., NORMAN, R. A., J, M. A. & PAZOUKI, K. 2015. An integrated multicriteria decision making methodology using compromise solution methods for prioritising risk of marine machinery systems. Ocean Engineering, 105, 92-103.

EMOVON, I., NORMAN, R. A. & MURPHY, A. J. A new Tool for Prioritising the Risk of Failure Modes for Marine Machinery Systems. Proceedings of the 33rd International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering OMAE14, June 8 - 13 2014 California United States,. Americal Society of Mechanical Engineers.

GOOSSENS, A. J. M. & BASTEN, R. J. I. 2015. Exploring maintenance policy selection using the Analytic Hierarchy Process; An application for naval ships. Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 142, 31-41.

GOPALASWAMY, V., RICE, J. A. & MILLER, F. G. 1993. Transit vehicle component maintenance policy via multiple criteria decision making methods. Journal of the Operational Research Society, 37-50.

HEADQUARTERS DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY 2006. Failures Modes, Effects and Criticality Analysis (FMECA) for command, control, communications, computer, intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance (C4ISR) facilities. Washington, DC.

HUANG, J., MILLER, C. R. & OKOGBAA, O. G. Optimal preventive-replacement intervals for the Weibull life distribution: solutions and applications. Reliability and Maintainability Symposium, 1995. Proceedings., Annual, 1995. IEEE, 370-377.

ILANGKUMARAN, M. & KUMANAN, S. 2009. Selection of maintenance policy for textile industry using hybrid multi-criteria decision making approach. Journal of Manufacturing Technology Management, 20, 1009-1022.

JARDINE, A. K. S., LIN, D. & BANJEVIC, D. 2006. A review on machinery diagnostics and prognostics implementing condition-based maintenance. Mechanical systems and signal processing, 20, 1483-1510.

JIANG, R., JI, P. & TSANG, A. H. C. 2006. Preventive effect of optimal replacement policies. Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, 12, 267-274.

KAHROBAEE, S. & ASGARPOOR, S. Risk-based failure mode and effect analysis for wind turbines (RB-FMEA). 2011.

LABIB, A. W., O'CONNOR, R. F. & WILLIAMS, G. B. 1998. An effective maintenance system using the analytic hierarchy process. Integrated Manufacturing Systems, 9, 87-98.

LAZAKIS, I. & OLCER, A. I. 2015. Selection of the best maintenance approach in the maritime industry under fuzzy multiple attribute group decision-making environment. Proc IMechE part M: Journal of Engineering for Maritime Environment, 1-13.

LAZAKIS, I., TURAN, O. & OLCER, A. I. Determination of the optimum Ship maintenance strategy through Multi Attribute Decision Making. 11th International Marine design conference 2012 Glasgow, Scotland, UK. 473-487.

LING, D., HUANG, H. Z., SONG, W., LIU, Y. & ZUO, M. J. Design FMEA for a diesel engine using two risk priority numbers. 2012.

MACHARIS, C., SPRINGAEL, J., DE BRUCKER, K. & VERBEKE, A. 2004. PROMETHEE and AHP: The design of operational synergies in multicriteria analysis.: Strengthening PROMETHEE with ideas of AHP. European Journal of Operational Research, 153, 307-317.

MAHESWARAN, K. & LOGANATHAN, T. 2013. A Novel Approach for Prioritisation of Failure modes in FMEA using MCDM. International Journal of Engineering Research and Application, 3, 733-739.

MOBLEY, R. K. 2001. Plant Engineers Handbook. JKB.

MOBLEY, R. K. 2004. Maintenance fundamental USA, Butterworth-Heinemann.

MOHAN, M., GANDHI, O. P. & AGRAWAL, V. P. 2004. Maintenance strategy for a coal-based steam power plant equipment: A graph theoretic approach. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part A: Journal of Power and Energy, 218, 619-636.

MOREIRA, M. P., DUPONT, C. J. & VELLASCO, M. M. B. R. PROMETHEE and fuzzy PROMETHEE multicriteria methods for ranking equipment failure modes. Intelligent System Applications to Power Systems, 2009. ISAP'09. 15th International Conference on, 2009. IEEE, 1-6.

MOUBRAY, J. 1991. Reliability-centred maintenance Buttenvorth. Heinemann Oxford.

NOEMI, M. P. & WILLIAM, L. 1994. maintenance scheduling issues, Results and Research needs. International Journal of operations and production management, 14, 47-69.

NYSTRÖM, B. & SÖDERHOLM, P. 2010. Selection of maintenance actions using the analytic hierarchy process (AHP): Decision-making in railway infrastructure. Structure and Infrastructure Engineering, 6, 467-479.

PILLAY, A. & WANG, J. 2003. Modified failure mode and effects analysis using approximate reasoning. Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 79, 69-85.

PILLAY, A., WANG, J. & WALL, A. 2001. Optimal inspection period for fishing vessel equipment: a cost and downtime model using delay time analysis. Marine Technology, 38, 122-129.

PINTELON, L., PINJALA, S. K. & VEREECKE, A. 2006. Evaluating the effectiveness of maintenance strategies. Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, 12, 7-20.

PRIDE, A. 2008. Reliability Centered Maintenance. Whole Building Design Guide [Online].

RAUSAND, M. 1998. Reliability centered maintenance. Reliability Engineering & System Safety, 60, 121-132.

RAUSAND, M. & VATN, J. 1998. Reliability Centered Maintenance. In: SOARES, C. G. (ed.) Risk and Reliability in Marine Technology. Balkema Holland.

RESOBOWO, D. S., BUDA, K. A. & DINARIYANA, A. A. B. 2014. Using Sensitivity Analysis for Selecting of Ship Maintenance Variables for Improving Reliability of Military Ship. Academic Research International, 5, 127.

SACHDEVA, A., KUMAR, D. & KUMAR, P. 2009a. Multi-factor mode criticality analysis using TOPSIS. Journal of Industrial Engineering International, 5, 9.

SACHDEVA, A., KUMAR, P. & KUMAR, D. 2009. Maintenance criticality analysis using TOPSIS. 2009 IEEE International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management, 2009b Hong Kong. 199-203.

SCIPIONI, A., SACCAROLA, G., CENTAZZO, A. & ARENA, F. 2002. FMEA methodology design, implementation and integration with HACCP system in a food company. Food Control, 13, 495-501.

SELVIK, J. T. & AVEN, T. 2011. A framework for reliability and risk centered maintenance. Reliability Engineering & System Safety, 96, 324-331.

SEYED-HOSSEINI, S. M., SAFAEI, N. & ASGHARPOUR, M. J. 2006. Reprioritization of failures in a system failure mode and effects analysis by decision making trial and evaluation laboratory technique. Reliability Engineering & System Safety, 91, 872-881.

SHAGHAGHI, M. & REZAIE, K. 2012. Failure Mode and Effects Analysis Using Generalized Mixture Operators. Journal of Optimization in Industrial Engineering, 11, 1-10.

SIDDIQUI, A. W. & BEN-DAYA, M. 2009. Reliability Centered Maintenance. Handbook of maintenance management. Springer.

STANOJEVIC, P., MASONIC, V. & BOVID, V. Maintenance Systems Organisation Structure Design Methodology Based on Modelling and Simulation. ESM'2000, Simulation Congress, 2000 Gent.

STANOJEVIC, P., MISKOVIC, V., BUKVIC, V. & ALEKSIC, M. 2004. Multilevel Maintenance Systems Influence Factors Analysis. Belgrade: Military-Technical Gazette.

SULLIVAN, G. P., PUGH, R., MELENDEZ, A. P. & HUNT, W. D. 2004. Operations and Maintenance Best practices: A Guide to achieving Operational efficiency. US: US Department of Energy.

TANG, Y., JING, J. J., YANG, Y. & XIE, C. 2014. Parameter Estimation of a Delay Time Model of Wearing Parts Based on Objective Data. Mathematical Problems in Engineering.

TRIANTAPHYLLOU, E., KOVALERCHUK, B., MANN JR, L. & KNAPP, G. M. 1997. Determining the most important criteria in maintenance decision making. Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, 3, 16-28.

VATN, J., HOKSTAD, P. & BODSBERG, L. 1996. An overall model for maintenance optimization. Reliability Engineering & System Safety, 51, 241-257.

VAVRA, B. 2007. Expert lay out a case for ROI of maintenance. . Plant Engineering, 61, 1-12.

VIDAL, L.-A., MARLE, F. & BOCQUET, J.-C. 2011. Using a Delphi process and the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) to evaluate the complexity of projects. Expert Systems with Applications, 38, 5388-5405.

WAEYENBERGH, G. & PINTELON, L. 2004. Maintenance concept development: A case study. International Journal of Production Economics, 89, 395-405.

WANG, L., CHU, J. & WU, J. 2007. Selection of optimum maintenance strategies based on a fuzzy analytic hierarchy process. International Journal of Production Economics, 107, 151-163.

WANG, W. 1997. Subjective estimation of the delay time distribution in maintenance modelling. European Journal of Operational Research, 99, 516-529.

WANG, W., BANJEVIC, D. & PECHT, M. 2010. A multi-component and multi-failure mode inspection model based on the delay time concept. Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 95, 912-920.

WANG, W. & JIA, X. 2007. An empirical Bayesian based approach to delay time inspection model parameters estimation using both subjective and objective data. Quality and Reliability Engineering International, 23, 95-105.

YANG, J., HUANG, H.-Z., HE, L.-P., ZHU, S.-P. & WEN, D. 2011. Risk evaluation in failure mode and effects analysis of aircraft turbine rotor blades using Dempster–Shafer evidence theory under uncertainty. Engineering Failure Analysis, 18, 2084-2092.

ZAIM, S., TURKYÍLMAZ, A., ACAR, M. F., AL-TURKI, U. & DEMIREL, O. F. 2012. Maintenance strategy selection using AHP and ANP algorithms: A case study. Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, 18, 16-29.

ZAMMORI, F. & GABBRIELLI, R. 2012. ANP/RPN: A multi criteria evaluation of the risk priority number. Quality and Reliability Engineering International, 28, 85-104.